Are Pickleball Beginners “Owed” Time with Stronger Players?

The debate is one that’s been raging in the sport for years: Should high level picklers “play down” with other members of their club?

The simplest answer is, “If they want to,” but with a bit of digging many different opinions come to light. Some feel that “open” play is just that, and believe it should be an opportunity to play the game and have fun heedless of skill divides. With this mindset, open play is an opportunity for picklers to mix things up rather than always sticking to their own.

Some clubs or communities have open play scheduled for a set period of time followed by rank-specific games at others. This allows high level players to choose whether they want to mingle among the intermediate crowd or stay with their peers, largely eliminating the feeling that they’re being “forced” to play with those outside their bracket. Unfortunately there aren’t always enough players or court availability to make this happen, which can lead to both parties feeling wronged.

Pickleball Station Class

An easy way to learn from the pros without taking time away from their open play is to invest in a class, like ours at Pickleball Station!

The best way to handle this situation uses qualities popular across the sport: respect and communication. It helps newer players feel included when pros generously take the time to play down, but they also shouldn’t be expected to constantly lower the playing field for the sake of others.

If a 4.5/5.0 says, “No, not right now,” because they have a competition coming up, haven’t had much opportunity to play with their peers or simply don’t feel like it that day, they shouldn’t be penalized. Newer players are not entitled to play with higher skill opponents unless they’re taking part in a class, and should be able to accept “no” gracefully.

In addition to this, it’s not even beneficial for average players to hit above their weight all the time. Does the pickler in question actually have the ability to “read” the game and determine areas they can improve, watch their opponent’s techniques and apply them, and focus on skill acquisition? Or are they just going to end up frustrated when they get beat, unable to understand where their own weaknesses lie?

Unless a player has the ability and awareness to pick these things out, playing above one’s skill just becomes an exercise in frustration. Playing someone of the same rank would’ve provided more fun, opportunity for improvement and reasonable challenge.

Green Valley Pickleball

A game at the Green Valley Pickleball courts

The Green Valley Pickleball Club in Arizona has a unique and organized way of addressing this topic by using monitors that show players if they’re in the wrong group. Each player is moved up or down depending on their performance. When someone wants to jump up a level, they must set up a ratings session and play with three picklers in their goal bracket, earning a total score of at least 21 points to progress.

This means that picklers can compete with opponents of a +- 0.5 skill level. It’s a small enough gap to avoid frustrating high level players while being reasonable enough to give the lower level player a proper challenge (without getting trounced).

How does your club handle skill imbalances? Do you prefer skill-specific brackets or enjoy the fluidity and community that open play provides? Share your thoughts in the comments.

5 thoughts on “Are Pickleball Beginners “Owed” Time with Stronger Players?

  1. and who to judge what level one is At on any given day anybody can Beat the best. I played racquetball and to inprove I played the best anyway in their mind

  2. In response to one of the above comments, everyone plays pickleball various different reasons. Some the social element, some exercise, some skill and challenge, some to improve and get good at something. If you are a good player and want to play with everyone, that is your choice, but the better players who want to improve and to have challenging games, they also should have a choice.
    I play for the cardio and the challenge and when I play with lower level players I do not break sweat and do not feel challenged and I get very bored. I think it can be made to be a win-win for everyone if there is more seperation of ability and awareness, as mentioned in the article.
    I think the article provided a good resolution by having a “monitor” and the lower level challenging the better players. I also like the comment that the lower level has to join in drills and clinics.
    Great article and great ideas for resolving the problem. Thank you.

  3. We have three courts and everybody knows that one is for beginners, second for intermediate and the third is for the more advanced players. I am happy to play with the lower level players, but only if they will also do some drills first. Otherwise they are just wasting their time and mine. “You can’t get the skills if you don’t do the drills” If they join in on our drills then we are happy to include them and help them improve. If they have no desire to drill then we don’t play with them.

  4. it’s an issue everywhere. I think you will come to the conclusion I have.. Just play with everyone most of the time and if you arrange a ‘good’ game.. yahoo. There are times / venues for those who think they are great.. hmmmm. Pickleball is best served without all the hype about 5.0 players at Indian Wells and charging huge sums for lessons with a pro that are identical to what you can easily learn for free from a friend that gives you baby steps to getting better..

  5. My club is struggling with this. Open play is too frustrating. Many cannot get into a groove waiting for competitive games. In addition to the lack of ladder play, we have a large number of intermediate “bangers”. Net play and dinking is sorely lacking. I am thinking i just need to take a break. Any advice is appreciated.

Leave a Reply